Concerted Effort: TRAP

M. Night Shyamalan’s Trap is probably his slightest and most straightforward movie to date. It’s pretty much always exactly what it appears to be, all right on the surface with no surprises. And yet his pacing, rhythm and plot progression is always so idiosyncratically his own that it’s still unexpected in its every development and every preposterous turn of events. More than any Shyamalan before, this one has little logic on a scene to scene basis, with plausibility, or even basic sense, almost completely subsumed by his workings of style, character, and theme. It makes for a minor work, but a vivid and telling one. He’s too good a filmmaker to let something like coherence or context throw him off his game. Forget having a plot hole or two; this movie’s Swiss cheese. But, hey, cheese can be a good treat, too, and my fellow Shyamalan auteurists will still find plenty to appreciate in the movie’s total refusal to be anything but itself. That is to say, it is, like his other recent efforts like Old and Knock at the Cabin, another outlandish premise in which a family is put to an ultimate test of togetherness.

Here we find Josh Hartnett as a doting dad taking his daughter to a pop concert, an event we quickly realize has been infiltrated by an FBI team on the hunt for a serial killer they have good reason to believe is in attendance. The twist lands quickly: Hartnett is that killer. Now he’s stuck surrounded by cops and crowds—and proceeds to plow unstoppably forward, like a shark on the move. He’s cornered, and needs to find his way out by working all the angles. That’s clever enough—and a more conventionally satisfying thriller might’ve milked its central concept more fully. Instead it’s played loosely for a few macabre moments and a lot of cringing comic stings. It never quite makes a full convincing space. The concert itself is a pretty flat affair—Shyamalan’s daughter Saleka plays a pop star simulacrum with songs that are bland and a performance a bit under-characterized and sketchily choreographed. And the variables at play in such a location are utilized rather sparingly as Hartnett eyes every potential escape route without rousing too much suspicion. Holding nearly every scene, he does a fine job of tight, restrained flailing, desperate to keep the ruse of normality from slipping. Then, without building to pop music crescendoes of payoffs, Shyamalan wriggles out of the expected and denies us the simple pleasures with a more eccentrically unexpected series of developments. We might think we’re watching a movie about a killer caught in a trap, but it’s soon clear it’s a movie about the traps we set for ourselves.

Here’s a man whose evil hobby has taken over his life. The unrealistic expectations he’s set for his nice suburban fatherhood persona colliding with his ugly urges threaten to ruin the good family man he could’ve been. He seems like a good dad—smiling, generous, bantering—and yet there’s a victim tied up in his basement. The friction between these halves of his identity is now grinding quickly toward imminent conflagration. The setup as rolled out was pretty far-fetched anyway. As Shyamalan lets it simmer as a twisted character piece instead, and gives a slow-rolling, high-pressure picture of a family life falling apart as it collides with the disjunctions and unexpected connections of stardom and screens and teens and the ways in which people can hide from each other in plain sight. The movie takes on a typically Shyamalanian frisson of pinned-back melodrama and ominous, geometrically composed implications that heighten the unreality of its murmured line readings and precise shell-game theatrics. It may have still left me wishing for the more conventional setups and payoffs the concert setting seemed to promise—but the more bitter interpersonal stakes of its increasingly small turns and odd shifts might end up lingering all the more.